Is 'Cook At Home' Always Good Health Advice?

By Melissa McEwen

Published January 9, 2015 at 3:09 PM EST

One reason cooking at home might be linked to poor health? Researchers say it could be because there are too many unhealthful baked goods coming out of the oven.

Author called home cooking the "single most important thing we could do as a family to improve our health and general well-being" in his 2013 book Cooked. And Michelle Obama told a crowd at the 2014 Building a Healthier Future Summit that "research clearly shows that home cooking is one of the single most impactful ways for families to improve their health."

But a recent study from researchers at Rush University in Chicago finds that the more time middle-aged women spent cooking at home, the more likely they were to suffer from metabolic syndrome, putting them at risk for heart disease and diabetes.

"We often emphasize cooking in our health interventions, but we hadn't seen a lot of conclusive evidence," says Bradley Appelhans, associate professor of preventive medicine at Rush University Medical Center and lead author of the study.

For the study, published in December in the journal Preventive Medicine, Appelhans and his co-authors analyzed data from the , or SWAN. This ongoing research endeavor collects data on the health of more than 2,000 women of different backgrounds from the age of 42 to 52 over the past 15 years. They're given a yearly health exam that includes a questionnaire about their habits. "In most households, women are the primary food preparer, so it's a logical group to study," says Appelhans.

For the study they tapped the SWAN data to see how cooking related to markers for metabolic syndrome — things like glucose levels, abdominal obesity, triglycerides, low HDL cholesterol (the good cholesterol) and hypertension. Having at least three of these markers qualifies a person as having metabolic syndrome. They also controlled for factors like employment status and menopausal status.

The results showed that the odds of having metabolic syndrome increased as the women aged, but the increase was faster among those who said they spent more time preparing meals. Interestingly, when they looked at the specific metabolic syndrome markers, meal preparation and cleanup time were associated with all of them except abdominal obesity.

One reason why cooking at home might be linked to disease in middle-aged women? Appelhans says that lots of baked treats — think brownies, cakes, pies — could "be lumped in there" with the cooking.

While the results are intriguing, they have limits. The data on cooking for SWAN hinge on that single self-reported question. And that question gleans nothing about what they cooked. One "possibility is that women who were at the highest risk for heart disease and diabetes were more motivated to cook meals at home," says Appelhans.

Appelhans notes there are many avenues of further study that could refine how we understand cooking as a health intervention. At midlife many people already have developed health problems — 23.4 percent of women in the SWAN cohort already had metabolic syndrome. "Women in midlife already have many patterns stable by this age," he says. "It would be quite interesting to follow individuals prospectively from early adulthood and see how meal preparation and cardiometabolic risk change together over their life."

While many cooking crusaders blame manufacturers of high-sugar, high-fat, high-salt packaged food for American's ill health, Appelhans says it's more complex than that. "Another thing to think about is many [prepared] foods have gotten much healthier — they've cut down on sodium, calorie content and created tasty alternatives to fast food and home-prepared meals," Appelhans says.

In another study at Rush, Appelhans and his team are looking at how different food sources from cooking at home to convenience stores contribute to health.

In the end Appelhans cautions that the take-home message for this paper isn't that cooking is bad, but that, "We need to ask more complicated questions about home food preparation and be cautious with simple public health messages like 'just cook more.' " The study conclusion says "public health interventions should place greater emphasis on cooking healthfully, not just cooking frequently."

Melissa McEwen is a freelance journalist based in Chicago.